Splinter Session

Multi-Dimensional Modelling of Substellar Atmospheres
Organizers:
Christiane Helling, St Andrews University, UK
Martin Asplund, MPI for Astrophysics (Garching), Germany
Peter Hauschildt, Hamburger Sternwarte, Germany

back to Cool Stars 16

all Splinter Sessions
Conference Program

Splinter's Program


Scientific Motivation

This splinter addresses the theory of atmospheres of very low mass objects. These atmospheres are so cool that a rich molecular gas-phase chemistry coupled with cloud formation processes determine their spectra. In particular clouds introduce a large opacity source in the atmosphere that strongly influence the radiation field and the hydrodynamic fluid field by radiative cooling. In addition, the formation of dust depletes the remaining element abundances, which feeds back into the radiation field as a decreased gas opacity. The modelling of substellar atmospheres has, hence, been much more demanding than initially anticipated with respect to mathematical modelling and numerical simulations.

Observations and theoretical arguments point us to the fact that the atmospheres of Brown Dwarfs and planets are very dynamic. First attempts to provide evidence did, however, struggle with the low contrast of the objects (e.g. Bailer-Johnes et al., Goldman et al.), but instruments like JWST and SPIKA are on their way and will provide much better data to match. Interferometry and polarimetry offer further possibilities to link multi-dimensional model simulations with observational findings.

This Splinter aims to stimulate a discussion on the present progress in multi-dimensional modelling of substellar atmospheres in relation to future observations and how to assess this progress with respect to the necessary coupling of hydrodynamic, radiative transfer and chemistry simulations. We aim to combine this assessment with future observational possibilities provided by interferometry, spectroscopy and polarimetry.

This Splinter will be driven by the questions
  • what multi-dimensional models can predict,
  • how reliable these predictions are,
  • which challenges we face, and
  • how to engage with future observational techniques

The Splinter will be composed of a number of invited talks and contributed talks with time for discussion as much as possible.

Invited Speaker
  • Svetlana Berdyugina (Kiepenheuer Institut fuer Sonnenphysik, Freiburg, D)
    Polarised Light: Revealing inhomogeneities in stars and planets
  • Ettore Pedretti (St Andrews, UK)
    Combined interferometry: challenges and possibilities to understand substellar variability
  • Ed Baron (Oklahoma, US)
    Generalized 3D radiative transfer for astrophysical atmospheres
  • Adam Showman (Arizona, US)
    Multi-dimensional hydro-simulations of substellar atmospheres
  • Program

    14:00 - 14:25 (20+5min)
    Ettore Pedretti (St Andrews, UK)
    Combined interferometry: challenges and possibilities to understand substellar variability
    14:25 - 14:50 (20+5min)
    Svetlana Berdyugina (Freiburg, D)
    Polarised Light: Revealing inhomogeneities in stars and planets
    14:50 - 15:05 (10+5min)
    Aline Vidotto (St Andrews, UK)
    Stellar influence on planet atmospheres is shocking
    15:05 - 15:20 (10+5min)
    Benjamin Beeck (Katlenburg-Lindau, D)
    MHD simulations revealing differences between solar and very-cool star magnetic structures
    coffee break 15:20 - 15:35 h
    15.35 - 16.00 (20+5min)
    Ed Baron (Oklahoma, US)
    Generalized 3D radiative transfer for astrophysical atmospheres
    16:00 - 16:25 (20+5min)
    Adam Showman (Arizona, US)
    Multi-dimensional hydro-simulations of substellar atmospheres
    16:25 - 16:40 (10+5min)
    Eric Agol (Univ of Washington, US)
    Weather pattern on a Hot Jupiter
    16:40 - 16:55 (10+5min)
    Derek Homeier (Goettingen, D)
    Convective overshooting and gravity waves as driver of non-equilibrium chemistry in ultracool atmospheres

    Abstracts
    • Polarised Light: Revealing inhomogeneities in stars and planets
      S.V. Berdyugina (Kiepenheuer Institut fuer Sonnenphysik, Freiburg; Germany)

      Polarimetry is a powerful technique for revealing two- and three-dimensional structures in astrophysical objects beyond the spatial resolution provided by direct imaging at any telescope. The light becomes polarized when interacting with an anisotropic medium, e.g., in the presence of magnetic fields or directed radiation beams. This anisotropy becomes imprinted into polarization properites of the light and can be inferred through polarized radiative transfer. I will demonstrate how such an analysis reveals 3D structure of starspots, presence of exoplanets and their properties as well as potentially inhomogeneities in exoplanetary atmospheres.

    • Stellar influence on planet atmosphere is shocking
      A. A. Vidotto, M. M. Jardine, Ch. Helling (University of St. Andrews, UK)

      Motivated by the recent observation on the light curve asymmetry of the transit hot-Jupiter WASP-12b, we propose a model where the interaction of the stellar plasma with the planet is able to modify the structure of the outer atmosphere of WASP-12b. The product of such interaction is the formation of a bow-shock ahead of the planetary orbital motion, which could explain the early transit ingress observed in the near-UV. We investigate the physical conditions of the external ambient medium around the planet that could allow for the formation of a bow-shock, and conclude that the compression of the planetary atmosphere should be a common effect in close-in planetary systems. In addition, our model provides a new technique to probe for the presence of a planetary magnetic field. In the case of WASP-12b, an upper limit for the planetary magnetic field strength ranges from 15 to 22G, comparable to the intensity of Jupiter's magnetic field. We discuss whether this effect could be detected by other techniques, such as interferometry and polarimetry.

    • MHD simulations reveal crucial differences between solar and very-cool star magnetic structures
      B. Beeck 1,2, M. Schuessler 1, and A. Reiners 2 (1 Max-Planck Institute for Solar System Research, Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany 2 University of Goettingen, Germany)

      Cool main-sequence stars of spectral types F through L have a thick convective envelope or are even fully convective. In many of such stars, magnetic fields of various strengths have been detected. In the Sun, the surface magnetic field is observed to be highly structured owing to its interaction with the convective flows. This has significant impact on the magnetic signatures in spectral lines that are used to detect and measure the field. In contrast to the Sun, the structure and properties of magnetic fields on other cool stars are unknown. In the absence of spatially resolved observations, the effect of the magnetic structure on signatures of the magnetic field can be evaluated by numerical simulations of the magneto-convective processes including the relevant physical processes, such as compressibility, partial ionization, and radiative energy transport. We carried out 3D radiative magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the convective and magnetic structure in the surface layers (uppermost part of the convection zone and photosphere) of main-sequence stars of spectral types F3 to M4. The simulation results were analyzed in terms of sizes and properties of the convection cells (granules) and magnetic flux concentrations as well as velocity, pressure, density, and temperature profiles, including their impact on observable quantities like spectral line shapes and micro-variability. Our numerical simulations show for the first time a qualitative difference in the magneto-convection between solar-like stars and M dwarfs. Owing to higher surface gravity, lower opacity (resulting in higher density at optical depth unity), and more stable downflows, small-scale magnetic structures concentrate into pore-like configurations of reduced intensity. This implies that in very cool stars magnetic surface structures like plage regions and starspots significantly differ from the solar example. Such a difference would have major impact on the interpretation of Doppler imaging data and the analysis of M dwarf spectra.

    • Generalized 3-D Radiative Transfer for Astrophysical Atmospheres
      Ed Baron (University of Oklahoma, US)

      I describe the development of our generalized stellar atmosphere code PHOENIX-3D. I describe our full characteristics method of solving the radiative transfer problem and show that it provides excellent results for both static and moving atmospheres in test problems. I discuss the implementation of both Eulerian and co-moving frame solutions for the case of moving atmospheres and discuss the computational advantages and disadvantages of both choices.

    • Multi-dimensional hydro-simulations of substellar atmospheres
      Adam Showman (University of Arizona, US)

      Of the many known extrasolar planets, over 100 have orbital semi-major axes less than 0.1 AU, and a significant fraction of these hot Jupiters and Neptunes are known to transit their stars, allowing them to be characterized with the Spitzer, Hubble, and groundbased telescopes. The stellar flux incident on these planets is expected to drive an atmospheric circulation that shapes the day-night temperature difference, infrared light curves, spectra, albedo, and atmospheric composition, and recent Spitzer infrared light curves seem to show evidence for dynamical meteorology in these planets' atmospheres. Here, I will survey basic dynamical ideas and detailed 3D numerical models that illuminate the atmospheric circulation of these exotic planets. I will describe the dynamical mechanisms for pumping and maintaining the fast jets that develop in these models, particularly the broad eastward (superrotating) equatorial jet that seems to be a near-universal feature of 3D models of synchronously rotating hot Jupiters on 2-4 day orbits. The role of friction in affecting the atmospheric circulation, and the conditions that promote time variability, will also be discussed.

    • Weather patterns on a Hot Jupiter
      Eric Agol, Nicolas Cowan (Univ. of Washington), Heather Knutson (UC Berkeley), Drake Deming (GSFC), Jason Steffen (Fermilab), Gregory Henry (Tennessee State), and David Charbonneau (Harvard)

      We observed seven transits and seven eclipses of the planet system HD 189733 at 8 microns with the IRAC camera on the Spitzer Space Telescope. With a new correction for the instrumental 'ramp' and for stellar variability, we are able to achieve relative photometry precise to 0.35 mmag over 590 days. With these advances, we are able to place limits on the dayside and nightside variability of the exoplanet, and show that the night side is 2/3 as bright as the day side, consistent with phase-function measurements for this system. We show that the secondary eclipse is offset from half of an orbital phase after transit due to the non-uniformity of the planet surface brightness (after correcting for light travel time across the system); this is in effect the first eclipse map of an exoplanet. We show that the system is consistent with zero eccentricity. We compute an updated ephemeris from the transit times which are measured to a precision of 3 seconds, and place limits on the presence of low mass companions in mean-motion resonances. We derive more precise parameters of the system, we show that the star is limb-darkened at this wavelength, consistent with stellar models, and we argue that the transits depths may be contaminated by star spots.

    • Convective overshooting and gravity waves as driver of non-equilibrium chemistry in ultracool atmospheres
      Derek Homeier, France Allard & Bernd Freytag (University of Goettingen, Germany / CRAL-ENS Lyon, France)

      Hydrodynamic turbulence is an important process shaping the conditions of atmospheres of brown dwarfs and young gas giant planets. Convection dominates the energy transport and thermal profile in the optically thick layers, but also drives turbulent mixing of the atmosphere inside the radiative regime, which in turn is responsible for the distribution of condensible material and departures from chemical equilibrium in the gas phase. 2D and 3D local radiation hydrodynamics simulations with the CO5BOLD code demonstrate that this turbulent velocity field can be described by a region of exponentially decreasing overshoot above the Schwarzschild boundary and the formation of gravity waves in the higher layers, with amplitude increasing with height. While the overshoot regime can contribute to the replenishment and support of low cloud layers, dust distribution at higher altitudes several non-equilibrium chemistry effects are primarily driven by gravity wave mixing. Based on the gravity wave model from these CO5BOLD simulations, we present calculations for the upmixing of carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, methane, nitrogen and ammonia under non-equilibrium conditions inside classical 1D PHOENIX stellar atmosphere models including detailed radiative transfer and high resolution synthetic spectra. The results reproduce well the observed mid-infrared spectra and photometry of cool T dwarfs and can also be applied to the first directly imaged extrasolar planets of the HR 8799 system.

    Call for Contributions

    We would like to invite you to participate in this Splinter Session.
    You can submit a short abstract via e-mail.
    Deadline for Splinter Session abstract submission: 29 July 2010

    Organisational stuff
    To participate in this splinter, you need to register for the main conference Cool Stars 16.
    Deadline for early conference registration: 15 July 2010
    (Register early to avoid disappointment. Last Cool Stars 15 has been oversubscribed by about 100 people!)

    Please refer to the Cool Stars 16 web page for information on
    Important dates,
    Travel,
    Accomodation
    all Splinter Sessions
    Conference Program
    and more.

    back to Cool Stars 16


    06.08.2010
    Christiane Helling